Analysis of school essays-reviews of the book read by different generations
DOI: 10.23951/2307-6127-2023-6-42-50
The report provides a comparative analysis of school essays on the topic “Review of a book read” written by sixth graders in 1985, 2005 and 2022. For analysis, the compositions of students from schools 88 (Seversk), 36, 49 schools (Tomsk) were used. A comparative analysis of the essays demonstrates how the reading preferences of Soviet schoolchildren (generation X), teenagers of generation zero (Y) and the modern generation (Z) have changed, and also shows the formation of textual competence among schoolchildren. Soviet schoolchildren loved to read books about exploits and heroism. Favorite authors are Reuvem Fraerman, Arkady Gaidar, Lev Davydychev. Generation zero was interested in adventures, science fiction, horror, children’s romance novels. Favorite authors – Robert Stein, Joan Rowling, John Ronald Ruel Tolkien, Sergey Lukyanenko. Digital children prefer comics, manga and fan fiction. Favorite authors are Ida Iro, Wakui Ken, Koeharu Gotoge, Diana Jones, Cornelia Funke. A comparison of the essays showed that Soviet schoolchildren were most conscientious about the task. The reviews have a clear structure, there is logic, one’s own opinion is expressed. The minus of the reviews is the ideology and the template. Millennial reviews do not have a clear composition, thoughts are expressed chaotically, but there are criticisms and jokes. The writings of digital children are the most concise, they do not contain reflections. Conclusions are presented regarding the prospects of working with teenagers in literature lessons
Keywords: textual competence, methods of teaching literature, theory of generations, generation X, millennials, zoomers, digital children, modern teenage literature, reading circle of teenagers, book review
References:
1. Rezul’taty obshcherossiyskoy otsenki po modeli PISA-2021 [The results of the all-Russian assessment according to the PISA-2021 model]. FGBU, «FIOKO» Publ., 2022. 79 p. (in Russian). URL: https://fioco.ru/Media/Default/Documents/Rezul’taty%20obshcherossiĭskoĭ%20ocenki%20po%20modeli%20PISA.pdf (accessed 1 february 2023).
2. Ozhiganova E. M. Teoriya pokoleniy N. Khouva i V. Shtrausa. Vozmozhnosti prakticheskogo primeneniya [The theory of generations by N. Howe and V. Strauss. Practical application possibilities]. Biznes-obrazovaniye v ekonomike znaniy, 2015, no. (1), pp. 94–97 (in Russian).
3. Bolotnova N. S. Tekstovaya kompetentsiya i puti eye formirovaniya v shkole [Textual competence and ways of its formation at school]. Kommunikativno-deyatel’nostnye i tekstoorientirovannye podkhody k prepodavaniyu russkogo yazyka: materialy nauchnoy konferentsii (12 marta 2001 g.) [Communicative-activity and text-oriented approaches to teaching the Russian language. Materials of the scientific conference (March 12, 2001)]. Tomsk, TSPU Publ., 2001. Pp. 66–67 (in Russian).
4. Lyashok A. S. «Deti perestroyki»: zhiznennye miry shkol’nikov 1980–1990-h godov [“Children of Perestroika”: the life worlds of schoolchildren of the 1980s – 1990s]. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta – Bulletin of Perm State University, Seriya: Istoriya, 2013, no. 2 (22), pp. 149–155 (in Russian).
5. Savenkova E.V. Kul’t pionerov-geroyev: zhertvennyy entuziazm v zhanre dlya srednego shkol’nogo vozrasta [The Cult of Pioneer Heroes: sacrificial enthusiasm in the genre for middle school age]. Vestnik Samarskoy gumanitarnoy akademii – Bulletin of the Samara Humanitarian Academy. Seriya «Filosofiya. Filologiya», 2005, no. 1 (17), pp. 43–53 (in Russian).
6. Federal’naya rabochaya programma osnovnogo obshchego obrazovaniya «Literatura» (dlya 5–9-kh klassov obrazovatel’nykh organizatsiy) [Federal work program of basic general education “Literature” (for grades 5–9 of educational organizations)]. Moscow, FGBNU «Institut strategii razvitii obrazovaniya» Publ., 2022. 123 p. (in Russian).
7. Skorobogat’ko E. Millenialy: osobennosti i problemy pokoleniya Y [Millennials: features and problems of Generation Y]. StudNet, 2018, no. 1, pp. 5 (in Russian).
8. 30 faktov o sovremennoy molodezhi: issledovaniye Sberbanka i Validata [30 facts about modern youth: Sberbank research and validation]. Yangspeys, 2017, no. 11 (in Russian). URL: http://youngspace.ru/faq/sberbankissledovanie-molodezhi (accessed 1 February 2023).
9. Dvoryanchikov Ya. V., Shepeleva E. S. Rol’ TikTok v sotsializatsii detey i podrostkov [The role of TikTok in the socialization of children and adolescents]. Forum molodyozhnoy nauki, 2021, no. 6, pp. 11–16 (in Russian).
10. Bryakotnina E. B., Poleva E. A. Izucheniye kruga chteniya podrostkov kak pedagogicheskaya problema [Studying the reading circle of teenagers as a pedagogical problem]. Nauchno-pedagogicheskoye obozreniye – Pedagogical Review, 2016, vol. 2 (12), pp. 129–134 (in Russian).
11. Oblasova T. V. Pochemu podrostki ne lyubyat chitat’ klassiku? [Why do teenagers not like to read classics?]. Filologicheskiy klass – Philological Class, 2020, vol. 25, no. 2, pp. 247–257 (in Russian).
12. Svirina N. M. Chteniye podrostkov: Rezul’taty issledovaniya i sravnitel’nyy analiz [Adolescent Reading: Research Findings and Comparative Analysis]. Filologicheskiy klass – Philological Class, 2017, no. 3 (49), pp. 64–72 (in Russian).
13. Lipovka V. O., Poleva E. A. Izucheniye chitatel’skikh interesov i potrebnostey semiklassnikov po rezul’tatam anketirovaniya [The study of the reader’s interests and needs of seventh graders based on the results of the questionnaire]. Kontsept, 2014, no. 07, pp. 81–85 (in Russian).
( 371.73 kB ) 
( 363.99 kB )
Issue: 6, 2023
Series of issue: Issue 6
Rubric: GENERAL EDUCATION
Pages: 42 — 50
Downloads: 220